Legalizing pot didn’t kill the black market, it created a marketing department for it

The marijuana legalization question sold Americans a elemental promise: legalize cannabis, modulate it, taxation it, and the achromatic marketplace would disappear.

That committedness has failed spectacularly.

Today, amerciable marijuana dealers stay progressive crossed California and passim the nation. Meanwhile, the "legal" marijuana manufacture — the precise manufacture that was expected to regenerate them — is struggling with declining sales, shrinking profits, surrendered licenses, and falling taxation revenues and concern loses.

The occupation is not that Americans person stopped utilizing marijuana. That would beryllium a large result for nationalist wellness and safety. The world is rather the opposite.

MARIJUANA IS NOT HARMLESS. THE OPPOSITE IS TRUE AND THE EVIDENCE KEEPS GROWING

National surveys amusement that cannabis usage continues to increase. According to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), past-month marijuana usage roseate from 37 cardinal Americans successful 2021 to much than 44 cardinal successful 2024, portion past-year usage besides reached grounds levels. Yet during the aforesaid period, California's "legal" cannabis income declined for 3 consecutive years. If request is increasing portion "legal" income are shrinking, the evident decision is that consumers are progressively obtaining marijuana from sources extracurricular the licensed marketplace.

Three Consecutive Years of Sales Declines successful California

Year — Legal Cannabis Sales:

2023 $4.4 billion

2024 $4.2 billion

2025 $3.9 billion

A cumulative diminution of astir 11% from 2023 to 2025.

This raises an uncomfortable question: What precisely has legalization accomplished?

The reply appears to beryllium that legalization created a government-endorsed marijuana manufacture that present performs galore of the functions erstwhile handled by the achromatic marketplace itself. Licensed marijuana dealers advertise cannabis products, normalize marijuana use, present caller customers to the drug, grow nationalist acceptance, and assistance turn wide demand. They run charismatic retail storefronts, make blase branding campaigns, and walk millions of dollars promoting marijuana consumption.

In doing so, they person efficaciously go the customer-acquisition limb of the broader marijuana economy.

Once consumers go accustomed to utilizing marijuana, galore observe that they tin acquisition the aforesaid merchandise done underground channels astatine importantly little prices. Illegal dealers bash not wage licensing fees, investigating costs, regulatory compliance expenses, labour mandates, information requirements, section taxes, authorities taxes, oregon national taxation burdens. As a result, they tin often undercut "legal" sellers connected terms portion benefiting from the accrued user request that legalization helped create.

In different words, licensed marijuana dealers are spending wealth to enlistee customers who tin aboriginal go customers of amerciable marijuana dealers.

MILLIONS OF ILLICIT CANNABIS PACKAGES DISGUISED AS CHILDREN'S CANDY SEIZED IN CALIFORNIA

California's numbers archer the story. The authorities present has much than 10,000 inactive oregon surrendered cannabis licenses, exceeding the fig of progressive licenses. Tax revenues that person been baked into metropolis and authorities budgets are declining. In San Diego, cannabis taxation collections person fallen dramatically from their post-legalization highs. Across the country, cannabis-related stocks person mislaid important worth with a large cannabis-sector money reporting a - 67.40% one-year instrumentality for the fiscal twelvemonth ended June 30, 2025, portion the S&P 500 was up 15.16% implicit the aforesaid period. Investors progressively admit that legalization has not produced the thriving, profitable manufacture that galore predicted.

The industry's defenders reason that legalization has reduced transgression enactment and accrued user safety. Yet the achromatic marketplace remains enormous. By immoderate estimates, implicit 60% marijuana consumed successful California is inactive obtained extracurricular the "legal" system.

The effect is simply a argumentation result nary legalization advocates anticipated but prevention specialists predicted. Rather than replacing amerciable cause dealers, legalization created a 2nd people of cause dealers — licensed, regulated, and taxed — who present vie with the archetypal ones.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

The irony is hard to ignore. The "legal" marijuana manufacture has spent years helping normalize cookware use, expanding user demand, and expanding nationalist acceptance of the drug. But overmuch of that expanded request continues to payment the precise underground marketplace legalization was expected to eliminate.

The achromatic marketplace has thrived. The "legal" marketplace is shrinking. And taxpayers should beryllium wondering whether the expansive promises of marijuana legalization were ever realistic successful the archetypal place.