AGQ’s Backwardation Squeeze Could Trigger a Delivery Default That Whipsaws Silver

Silver bulls yet got their moonshot. ProShares Ultra Silver, the 2x regular leveraged metallic futures ETF, returned astir 184% implicit the past twelvemonth arsenic a COMEX physical-delivery compression reshaped the futures curve. Yet the aforesaid money is down astir 28% twelvemonth to date, a reminder that this merchandise was engineered for a azygous trading day, not for the benignant of multi-month thesis metallic investors typically hold.

That hostility betwixt the fund's mechanical plan and however investors really usage it is the full communicative of ProShares Ultra Silver (NYSEARCA:AGQ).

What AGQ Is Built To Do

AGQ is simply a derivatives-based money that targets doubly the regular instrumentality of a metallic futures benchmark utilizing a stack of futures contracts, swaps, and different derivatives. The intended portfolio relation is tactical: short-term, directional speculation connected metallic terms moves implicit hours oregon days. It is built for trading, not for the buy-and-hold inflation-hedge relation metallic itself often plays.

The instrumentality motor has 3 moving parts. First, the money holds front-month metallic futures, which means returns way the futures terms alternatively than spot silver. Second, leverage is reset daily, truthful the 2x narration lone holds implicit a azygous session. Third, erstwhile futures rotation guardant each month, the outgo of that rotation either adds to oregon subtracts from returns depending connected whether the curve is successful contango oregon backwardation.

That 3rd lever is wherever the existent setup gets interesting. Open involvement successful metallic futures has dwindled toward 100,000 contracts arsenic carnal request pulls metallic disconnected COMEX, pushing the curve into backwardation. Backwardation is antithetic for metallic and, successful theory, tin nutrient a affirmative rotation output for AGQ. It besides raises the process hazard of a transportation default, an lawsuit that could whipsaw metallic futures violently successful either direction.

The expert who called NVIDIA successful 2010 conscionable named his apical 10 stocks and ProShares wasn't 1 of them. Get them present FREE.

Promise Versus Reality

The 12-month instrumentality looks similar vindication for AGQ holders, but the longer arc is brutal. Over 5 years, AGQ returned astir 145%, and implicit 10 years, conscionable 167%, contempt metallic itself going done aggregate large rallies. One Reddit poster connected r/investing summarized the acquisition aft buying adjacent a anterior peak: "Getting backmost to interruption adjacent connected AGQ aft 15 years." That is the volatility decay taxation successful plain English.

The mathematics down it is simple. Daily resetting compounds losses faster than gains successful choppy markets. A 10% driblet followed by a 10% rebound leaves metallic astir flat; the aforesaid way leaves a 2x regular money down meaningfully. The VIX spike to astir 31 successful precocious March, followed by a drawback backmost to astir 17 is precisely the benignant of round-trip that erodes leveraged ETFs adjacent erstwhile their underlying ends adjacent wherever it started.