Attorney who defended DC sniper says Kohberger faces 'monumental uphill battle' undoing guilty plea

Bryan Kohberger faces a "monumental uphill battle" successful his effort to retreat his blameworthy plea successful the murders of 4 University of Idaho students, according to an lawyer who represented D.C. sniper Lee Boyd Malvo and erstwhile helped different lawsuit successfully retreat a blameworthy plea earlier winning an acquittal.

Mark Petrovich, who represented Malvo successful post-conviction proceedings successful Virginia and has decades of transgression defence experience, told Fox News Digital that defendants seldom win successful withdrawing blameworthy pleas aft sentencing, adjacent successful cases involving claims that they were unaware of perchance exculpatory grounds earlier entering the plea.

He cautioned against drafting nonstop comparisons betwixt Malvo's post-conviction litigation and Kohberger's effort to retreat his blameworthy plea. Malvo's appeals stemmed from changes successful law instrumentality governing juvenile sentencing, portion Kohberger is attempting to undo a plea statement helium entered arsenic an big aft avoiding the decease penalty.

KAYLEE GONCALVES' MOTHER SAYS FAMILY READY FOR TRIAL AFTER BRYAN KOHBERGER SEEKS TO WITHDRAW GUILTY PLEA

"It's a monumental uphill battle," Petrovich said. "First of all, getting the justice to let you to retreat the plea, and past 2nd of each to winning immoderate caller proceeding, due to the fact that there's a batch against you."

Bryan Kohberger appears astatine the Ada County Courthouse for his sentencing proceeding connected July 23, 2025, successful Boise, Idaho. Kohberger pleaded blameworthy successful speech for being spared the decease punishment for the stabbing of 4 University of Idaho students astir 3 years ago. (Kyle Green-Pool/Getty Images)

Kohberger pleaded blameworthy successful July 2025 to the stabbing deaths of University of Idaho students Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle, Madison Mogen and Kaylee Goncalves successful Moscow, Idaho, successful November 2022. He was sentenced to 4 consecutive beingness sentences without the anticipation of parole aft accepting a plea statement that spared him from the decease penalty.

FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X

In caller tribunal filings, Kohberger claimed helium was pressured into accepting the plea agreement, did not afloat recognize perchance exculpatory grounds earlier pleading blameworthy and was misled astir the conditions helium would look portion incarcerated.

IDAHO MURDERS: NEW BOOK ON KOHBERGER REVEALS PREVIOUSLY UNSEEN EVIDENCE, CLAIMS SHEATH COULD BE INADMISSIBLE

He contends those factors undermined the voluntariness of his determination to plead guilty.

Petrovich said helium erstwhile represented a lawsuit who sought to retreat a blameworthy plea earlier sentencing. A justice granted the request, the lawsuit proceeded to proceedings and the lawsuit was acquitted, but helium said Kohberger's circumstances are fundamentally antithetic due to the fact that helium has already been sentenced.

In this Oct. 20, 2003 record photo, Lee Boyd Malvo listens to tribunal proceedings during the proceedings of chap sniper fishy John Allen Muhammad successful Virginia Beach, Va.

SIGN UP TO GET THE LATEST TRUE CRIME NEWS

"You can't hold until aft you're sentenced and spot what the consequences of the plea are and past alteration your plea," Petrovich said. "It's going to beryllium a very, precise hard load to overcome."

ALEX MURDAUGH MURDER SAGA LANDS RIGHT BACK WHERE IT STARTED BEFORE NEXT LOWCOUNTRY COURTROOM BATTLE

Petrovich said Kohberger would look 2 important hurdles adjacent if a justice allowed him to retreat his plea.

One would beryllium convincing jurors aft antecedently admitting guilt nether oath.

LIKE WHAT YOU'RE READING? CLICK HERE FOR MORE

Even if a justice allowed Kohberger to retreat his plea, Petrovich said jurors would astir surely larn helium had already admitted guilt, creating different important obstacle astatine trial.

Bryan Kohberger attends a presumption proceeding astatine Latah County District Court successful Moscow, Idaho, U.S., January 12, 2023. (Kai Eiselein/Pool via REUTERS)

SEND US A TIP

"One happening that's important is that you inactive can't fell from the assemblage the information that you said nether oath that you're guilty," Petrovich said. "Even if you withdraw, past you person to explicate that ... if you're going to get anyplace with immoderate benignant of assemblage finding."

Petrovich besides questioned whether Kohberger's attorneys would person advised him to judge a plea statement without archetypal reviewing the grounds disclosed during discovery.

GOT A TIP?

He noted that defence attorneys handling superior cases typically walk years reviewing find earlier recommending whether a lawsuit should plead guilty.

"The attorneys connected the lawsuit ... were intimately acquainted with the grounds and the accusation that was provided to them by instrumentality enforcement and prosecution," Petrovich said. "I'm definite they knew each astir everything. If they encouraged him oregon if determination was a treatment and a plea was decided on, I'm definite it was for bully reason."

LISTEN TO THE NEW 'CRIME & JUSTICE WITH DONNA ROTUNNO' PODCAST

Kohberger's lawsuit is not the archetypal involving a notorious slayer who aboriginal sought to undo a blameworthy plea.

Madison Mogen, apical left, smiles connected the shoulders of her champion friend, Kaylee Goncalves, arsenic they airs with Ethan Chapin, Xana Kernodle, and 2 different housemates successful Goncalves' last Instagram post, shared the time earlier the 4 students were stabbed to death. (@kayleegoncalves/Instagram)

James Earl Ray pleaded blameworthy successful 1969 to assassinating the Rev. Martin Luther King Jr. to debar a imaginable decease sentence. Three days aft entering his blameworthy plea, Ray sought to retreat it, arguing helium had been pressured into confessing. He spent the remainder of his beingness trying to undo the plea but died successful situation successful 1998 without ever receiving the assemblage proceedings helium sought.

GET BREAKING NEWS BY EMAIL

Serial slayer Clifton Bloomfield unsuccessfully sought to retreat blameworthy pleas aft admitting to 5 murders successful New Mexico to debar superior punishment. Washington serial slayer Robert Lee Yates Jr. besides challenged his plea statement aft admitting to murdering 13 women, but courts yet rejected some efforts.

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

Kohberger's plea statement spared him from facing a superior proceedings and ended years of pretrial litigation successful 1 of the country's astir intimately watched execution prosecutions.

Petrovich said that history, combined with the years of find and plea negotiations starring up to Kohberger's agreement, makes the effort to retreat it particularly difficult.