Are Trump and Xi making a genuine breakthrough or is China stringing us along … again?

President Donald Trump’s acme with Chinese President Xi Jinping past week was historic. Was it the pivotal infinitesimal that ends Cold War 2.0?

There were fewer details announced during the event, but connected Sunday the White House released its information expanse connected commitments Beijing made.

There is ever a renewal of optimism erstwhile American and communist Chinese leaders meet. There are, however, 2 peculiar reasons suggesting caution astatine this moment.

First, Washington is backmost to talking to China, which has traditionally utilized discussions to transportation American presidents to hold taking action. And portion Americans delayed, China has continued unacceptable conduct.

CHILL COMING FROM TRUMP’S SUMMIT WITH XI IS PROOF OF A NEW COLD WAR WITH CHINA

The country arsenic President Donald Trump participates successful events astatine the Great Hall of the People and does a greeting with the President of China Xi Jinping May 14, 2026, successful Beijing, China, during a travel focused connected trade, determination information and strengthening bilateral ties betwixt the world’s 2 largest economies. (Kenny Holston/Pool via Reuters)

Take fentanyl, which has caused "the deadliest cause epidemic successful history." Trump returning to Washington connected Air Force One confirmed helium raised the contented with Chinese President Xi Jinping.

Xi has made 4 promises to American presidents connected the topic: to President Barack Obama successful 2016, to Trump successful 2018, to President Joe Biden successful 2023, and to Trump again successful 2025. The Chinese person has violated each his pledges.

Trump, to his credit, imposed an further 20% fentanyl tariff connected Chinese goods past year. But arsenic Sara Carter, his cause czar, said successful March, China has continued income of precursors for the deadly synthetic opioid.

TRUMP SAYS CHINA WILL WORK WITH HIM TO STOP FENTANYL TRAFFICKING

The clip for talking astir this peculiar topic, therefore, should beryllium over, but Washington has conscionable allowed Xi to bargain adjacent much time.

Second, Xi displayed an assertive cognition during the summit. On Thursday, helium publically mentioned the Thucydides Trap, a notation to a declining hegemon dangerously challenging a rising power. The insult to Trump — and America itself — was striking.  

"Xi’s urging that China and the U.S. flooded the Thucydides Trap and make a caller paradigm of major-country relations signals his anticipation that the West volition judge the inevitability of being overtaken by China and truthful not situation it anyplace connected earth," Charles Burton of the Sinopsis deliberation vessel told maine aft the summit.

BEHIND SUMMIT SMILES, XI GIVES BLUNT WARNING TO TRUMP OF 'CLASHES' AND 'CONFLICTS'

Even worse, the Chinese person connected the summit’s archetypal time talked astir the "new era," Xi’s operation for the play successful which the U.S. has been pushed to the sidelines and China dominates the world. "Change is coming that hasn’t happened successful 100 years," Xi successful March 2023 told Russian President Vladimir Putin successful Moscow aft their 40th in-person meeting. "And we are driving this alteration together."

To marque the meaning of "new era" unmistakable, the Chinese overseas ministry announced, connected the 16th, that Putin volition beryllium visiting Beijing, starting May 19.

Second, Xi displayed an assertive cognition during the summit. On Thursday, helium publically mentioned the Thucydides Trap, a notation to a declining hegemon dangerously challenging a rising power. The insult to Trump — and America itself — was striking.  

As Burton noted, "Xi views himself arsenic thd modern heir of China’s lineage of large emperors, truthful the conception of just and reciprocal relations with immoderate overseas state is simply absent from his worldview."

GORDON CHANG: CHINA'S RISING MARKETS MASK A FRAGILE ECONOMY, SOCIAL DISCONTENT

Xi has agelong been pushing the imperial-era conception that China is the world’s lone sovereign state. Chinese emperors believed they not lone had the Mandate of Heaven to regularisation tianxia — "All Under Heaven" — but besides that Heaven compelled them to bash so.

Xi has often utilized tianxia language. "The Chinese person ever held that the satellite is agreed and each nether eden are 1 family," helium declared successful his 2017 New Year’s Message.

Moreover, Chinese officials person continually propagated tianxia themes. As Foreign Minister Wang Yi wrote successful Study Times, the influential Central Party School newspaper, "Xi Jinping thought connected diplomacy" — a "thought" successful Party-speak is an important assemblage of ideology — "has made innovations connected and transcended the accepted Western theories of planetary relations for the past 300 years."

TRUMP’S CHINA THAW LEAVES TAIWAN DECISION LOOMING AS EX-NBA STAR WARNS ISLAND HOLDS KEY TO US AI RACE

President Donald Trump participates successful a invited ceremonial with China's President Xi Jinping astatine the Great Hall of the People, Thursday, May 14, 2026, successful Beijing. (Mark Schiefelbein/AP Photo)

Wang, with his clip reference, was pointing to the Peace of Westphalia of 1648, 2 treaties that established the existent planetary bid of competing sovereign states. Wang’s usage of "transcended," consequently, hints that Xi wants a satellite without sovereign states, successful different words, a unified satellite ruled by the Chinese.

How tin immoderate federation cooperate with a China that believes others person nary sovereignty?

Charles Payne, the Fox Business anchor, intriguingly suggested to Fox anchor Jesse Watters that the Trump-Xi acme is an echo of an earlier dialogue: "This has a accidental to go a Reagan-Gorbachev No. 2."

COULD TRUMP'S MEETING WITH PUTIN BE THE NEXT REAGAN-GORBACHEV MOMENT?

Payne’s humanities analogy is acold person to the people than Xi’s.

China astatine the infinitesimal is not rising, arsenic Xi, with his Thucydides Trap and "new era" references, implied. China’s system is deteriorating, the spot marketplace is plunging, the Communist Party is racked by purges, the subject is successful disarray and galore radical are either aggravated oregon person opted retired of society. Most fundamentally, the country’s demography is collapsing: China volition astir surely suffer much than fractional its colonisation by the crook of the century.

CLICK HERE FOR MORE FOX NEWS OPINION

Former Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev, who besides prevailed implicit a failing state, is wide hailed arsenic a leader due to the fact that helium recognized that the USSR could not beryllium saved. In China’s ruling circles, however, helium is vilified.

"Why did the Soviet Union disintegrate? Why did the Soviet Communist Party collapse?" Xi Jinping asked successful a concealed code to Guangdong state cadres successful December 2012, 1 period aft being named wide caput of China’s ruling organization. "An important crushed was that their ideals and convictions wavered."

CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THE FOX NEWS APP

"Finally, each it took was 1 quiescent connection from Gorbachev to state the dissolution of the Soviet Communist Party, and a large enactment was gone," Xi declared successful Guangdong. "In the end, cipher was a existent man, cipher came retired to resist."

President Ronald Reagan, successful his dialog with Gorbachev, was capable to stabilize relations truthful that the Soviet Union could dissolve without catastrophe. Xi, unfortunately, is acold much determined than the Soviet leader, truthful Trump’s situation to negociate a faltering China volition beryllium greater.

CLICK HERE TO READ MORE FROM GORDON CHANG